Windows Live Spaces: Community vs. Individuality

I’ve cooled off a bit since August 1st when the MSN Spaces butterfly crawled back into it’s cocoon to become Windows Live Spaces.  But I have to say I was steaming pretty well right after the transition - if I’d have had more time before I cooled off I probably would have moved this blog elsewhere.
 
First off, the thing didn’t work worth a darn - I couldn’t get editing to even work, and most pages once I signed in displayed as utter garbage.  Perhaps the stylesheets weren’t coming down properly, but also many images were totally off - templates and background patterns seemed completely random.  I was using my mom’s computer, with IE6, but it took a couple of days before the site seemed to settle down enough to use.  Being remote and having problems made me realize how much I come to rely on the blog to be there when I want it.  When it doesn’t work, it actually hurts me - prevents me from expressing myself.  But these initial troubles seemed to have worked themselves out.
 
And then the layout changed, which is not necessarily a bad thing - I was already wondering how to increase the font size without re-editing all my blog entries.  But even subtle changes can be disorienting and mess up any layout I’d attempted to do.  Namely, the width of the blog increased well past the recommended number of words per line, making the text harder to read (as if it wasn’t hard enough), messing up many embedded photos, and making the blog too wide to read on an 800×600 monitor (there still are some poor souls who do that apparently).  Fortunately my HTML is quite pure, but I read some comments by people with a lot of special formatting that were not happy.  I finally realized I could shrink the width, not by special fixed-width DIVs in each entry, but by using a three-column layout.  I guess I’ll have to live with another column of fluff to keep the central content in line…
 
But the main thing that I can’t get used to is the rebranding.  My blog page used to be titled "Design By Committee".  Right up there at the top.  The title announced the page first and foremost as mine.  I owned it.  Even the URLs have evolved for the better, putting me, auburnmarshes, right up front before "spaces.msn.com" or "spaces.live.com".  The Space, and even the URL, was mine!
 
The new design has sure put me back in my lowly place!  The page starts off with a big honkin’ ad that screams, "this page is primarily here to serve ads", which I can almost forgive.  After all, I’m getting a great service for free, and I am happy to return the favor by bringing the few eyeballs I can manage to Space’s advertisers.  But a smaller ad (or several) integrated into the page better, at least below the page title, would have made me feel like the page was still primarily mine.
 
The killer is that after you get below the ad, what’s the page titled?  Windows Live Spaces.  It’s no longer my page, it’s clearly marked as Microsoft’s.  Mine is just the same, modulo some colored themes, as everyone else’s.  That impression is further reinforced by the hierarchy that’s provided just below the banner.  "Spaces > Design by Committee".  I’m just an insignificant player, completely dominated by the juggernaut which is Spaces.  Rather dehumanizing, wouldn’t you say?
 
Finally, if one has persisted this far, down below the "fold" of the banner, at last you might stumble across the actual title of my blog.  It’s buried there in the no-man’s-land of web page real estate.  We’re used to picking up the gist of the page from the banner, then skipping a bunch of crud to get to the content.  The title is now in that skippable-crud zone.  The title doesn’t even get a higher priority than any other random bit of content or space-wasters that might be there, namely, the title doesn’t go full width but must fit into the jigsaw jumble of page parts.  Heck, I could even put the title after the blog if I wanted to.  Isn’t that useful functionality?  Perhaps it supports all those popular bottom-to-top writing directions?
 
Many of the new features in Windows Live Spaces are about community - friends lists and navigation, social networking, etc.  Which I still don’t really get (seems like a violation of my privacy if you list me publicly as your friend), though perhaps some people may like to think of themselves as parts of a community first, and individuals second.  I prefer to think of myself first as an individual, secondarily as part of a community.  And I want to choose the community.  Windows Live Spaces is a bit too big and impersonal to really feel like a community to me - it still feels like a brand.  The update to Windows Spaces Live has taken that away from me, and having your individuality constrained certainly does not increase my loyalty to the site.
 
I thought the Live guys were starting to understand that putting the user at the center of the Web was part of embracing the Web.  When you do that you create services that users develop a strong relationship with.  My relationship with MSN Spaces was strong, but my relationship with Windows Live Spaces could use a little bit of counseling right now…

Tahoe Rim Trail: Day 9

[Written Aug 5th, 8PM.  Pictures here.]

Today was full of wonders, maybe the perfect backpacking day yet!

This section, Kingsbury Grade to Big Meadow, encircles the southeast corner of the Lake.  My new friend Coy and I are doing it as "guy’s day out".  We met at Big Meadow and did the car shuttle for an 11AM start at the Kingsbury end.  I am a bit embarrassed to say, but I made Coy walk with me the mile-plus of pavement up to the trailhead so I can keep my claim intact of walking all the way around Tahoe.

From the trailhead up under the Heavenly Valley ski lifts, we chatted amiably and the first five passed quickly, bringing me past the 100-mile mark!  Suddenly we were traversing a steep slope that dropped off 3000 feet to the Carson Valley floor.  Minden, Gardnerville, Carson City to the north, set among streams and hayfields colored purple in blotches as clouds rolled overhead, spawned by Freel Peak.

Carson Valley panorama

The dramatic Carson Valley views persisted up to a broad sandy saddle called Monument Pass.  As we emerged from the pass Freel Peak appeared, framed by whimsical boulder formations below and by emerging thunderclouds above.  Job’s Sister, slightly lower than Freel but with a more dramatic face of cliffs and snowfields, also became visible.

Monument Pass

As we approached these thunderheads, traversing the ridge on the Upper Truckee side, they began to throw a few large, sharply-cold drops our way.  The sky to the west was still clear blue and we surmised the sun-shiny shower wouldn’t last the proverbial half-hour.  But it did, and turned into a gradual intermittent sprinkle through most of the afternoon.

Old-growthSoon we entered a high saddle of old-growth juniper trees - not dramatically tall but with impressive girths.  They reminded me of baobab trees, or something from Myst.  We took shelter under one as we heard a rushing sound approaching and sat for a few minutes as the sprinkling intensified into a downpour - even a few hailstones.  Thunder rolled in slow crescendoes from the east.

Star LakeWe finished the last bit of trail to Star Lake, chose a tent spot not already occupied by a tent, and enjoyed a warm nap in the sun.  We could still see a few drops making rings in the water’s otherwise still surface, but not really feel anything.

Boots offCooling our feet in the chilly lake water felt good, and we established our kitchen on flat lake-side rocks with views both of the peaks to the southeast, and the setting sun to the west.  We dined elegantly on avocado stuffed with cherry tomatoes and imitation Crab, Morrocan Couscous with sun-dried cherry tomatoes, pine nuts and curry, and with an envelope of Palak Paneer over rice - leaving us both stuffed and mellow.

Star Lake sunsetI write this under the last color of the setting sun - not overly dramatic as the clouds have by now almost all wandered off eastward, but with still waters disturbed only by jumping fish, and by the reflection of the almost-full moon rising large between the dual peaks of Job’s Sister.

How else could such a perfect day end?

[Mileage: 10.5 | 105.8]